Modals, Drawers & Overlays
Modals are easy to reach for and easy to overuse. Every source we track says to use them sparingly, and each one draws the line in a slightly different place: what deserves an interruption, what belongs in a drawer, and what should get its own page.
9 of 11 systems allow modals for short, focused tasks as well as critical decisions, and 6 of 8 say never to open one modal from another. 6 of 8 also show a visible close button on every modal, even one that asks for a decision. Long tasks are less settled. 4 of 7 move them to their own page, while Shopify Polaris, Adobe Spectrum, and Apple HIG use a full-screen modal. For most systems, whether a backdrop click closes the modal depends on whether it holds a decision or unsaved input.
- systems tracked
- 19
- sources cited
- 20
- evidence cards
- 153
- questions tallied
- 6
Popular questions
Each one is researched across every system we track. Pick one and it opens in chat, ready to send.
Systems tracked
The same core design systems are tallied on every topic, so answers compare like with like. See every source
- GOV.UK
- IBM Carbon
- Shopify Polaris
- Google Material 3
- Atlassian
- GitHub Primer
- Adobe Spectrum
- Microsoft Fluent
- Salesforce Lightning
- Ant Design
- Mozilla Acorn
- Stripe Apps
- shadcn/ui
- Porsche Design System
- Base Web
- GitLab Pajamas
- Radix UI
- USWDS
- Pinterest Gestalt
Got a modals, drawers & overlays question?
Your first 3 questions are free. Every answer comes with the sources behind it.